Travelers is the best car insurance company in Indiana in our analysis ...

WSJ Buy Side is The Wall Street Journal’s research and commerce team. Our commerce content is distinct from our newsroom coverage. We earn a commission from some links in our articles. Learn more.

For young drivers: Travelers, $145 For middle-aged drivers: Travelers, $77 For senior drivers: Geico, $83; Travelers, $84 Cheapest by driving record For drivers with an at-fault accident: Travelers, ...